This leads to the demise of democracy

Saturday 11th April 2009, 2:59PM BST.

From Nellie Maçon.
JERSEY was governed for centuries by unpaid, wealthy States Members with few voices of opposition in the States or among the public because nobody dared or could afford to oppose them.

However, nowadays the public are better educated and with paid States Members, ordinary people can now truly represent the voices of the people.

There is an element among the higher echelons in Jersey which cannot tolerate this and because they have never dealt with opposition on this scale before, they simply do not know how to handle it. They therefore use the tactics more usually seen in regimes such as Zimbabwe, China and the former Soviet bloc countries in an attempt to intimidate and silence the voices of dissent.

To silence me personally for opposing them at the Senatorial hustings they misquoted my private correspondence in order to humiliate me and try to silence me (this had nothing to do with Deputy Maçon at all).

However, as a rule I never give in to bullies, so this was unsuccessful. In the case of the JDA they passed the Public Elections (Amendment No 3) (Jersey) Law 2008 to try to prevent them being re-elected – again they failed, so now they are taking this law to its extreme and making the process as drawn out and painful as possible for Deputies Southern and Pitman.

Finally, in the case of Senator Syvret, they invaded the privacy of his home without a search warrant and gained access to privileged information. Should anyone who corresponded with Senator Syvret now expect this private correspondence to be ‘leaked’ or used against them? Further, that eight police officers were deployed to arrest one individual is surely excessive.

What can we now expect in future? Can a private individual expect the privacy of their home to be invaded and ransacked simply because they have the courage to voice opinions contrary to prominent States Members and those in the higher echelons of society?

I certainly do not condone law-breaking and States Members who break the law can expect to be punished. However, why do we see States Members who have broken similar laws getting away with a rap over the knuckles simply because they are in favour with powerful people? Why do we allow judges to preside over cases where there is a clear conflict of interest and why are States departments not accountable when they cause small businesses to lose vast amounts of money, as in the case of the Pinels?

Where is this all leading to apart from the demise of democracy? What hope is there for the constitutional changes that the people of Jersey are crying out for, if those championing these changes are being bullied and intimidated in order to silence them?

We have almost three more long years before these matters can be addressed but how much of this abuse of power will the electorate remember at that time and how many will actually use their vote for change? Unless they do so there is no hope for justice and democracy in Jersey.
Beau Regard,
Plat Douet Road,
St Saviour.


  1. 1
    ronnie

    Mrs Macon,If you were so keen to voice your opinions you should have stood for deputy yourself, instead of getting your son elected.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Nellie Macon

    Ronnie (without a surname) at least I have the courage to put my name to my opinions.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    J G

    Well said Nellie – and Ronnie, mrs Macon did not ‘get her son elected’, the people of the Parish did that.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Linda

    Very well put Nellie, you’ve hit the nail on the head. I’m just not sure we can afford or bear to wait three long years.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Adrian

    I don’t think we live in a democracy anyway as we have nearly 10% who are unelected in the States who are pro-establishment. Is this right in the 21st century?

    What chance a change of government? Nil in my opinion until the States structure is changed.

    As far as I am concerned we have had the same government in power since WW2, not bad for any government. Can many other countries boast this type of democracy?

    As per policing then if this is the way things are going I view it as a step much nearer the police state as talked about in 1984 by George Orwell. Maybe when we have SWOT teams roaming the streets for wrong doers we will be there?

    We already have double think, Big Brother and Newspeak in everyday use from what I can see.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Ronnie 2

    I am writing my name as I do not want to be confused with the Ronnie in comments 1 and 3, thanks for being on of the invaluable few who tell it how it really is… now as for the rest of the bully boy tactics used by States members and financially well off, more people need to stand up to these morons and their self sufficient views and interests.

    I think its a good thing that your son has an interest in politics as so many youngsters are too busy causing trouble or baaing like sheep to win the Jersey popularity contests which unfortunately a majority of our islanders do to keep face and to fit in. Stuff conforming and stuff sheep, stuff the get rich quick mentality that so many are fooled by and almost bullied into for fear of being ridiculed for being aware, open minded and having a higher state of consciousness.

    Keep up the good work and thanks for being for the people and not just the money.

    Report abuse