There are many avenues commercial fishermen might explore
Tuesday 30th June 2009, 2:59PM BST.
From Peter Gosselin.
I WRITE in response to the curious letter from Jason Bonhomme (JEP, 22 June). Firstly I must state that I am writing as an individual, not as the representative of the Recreational Fishermen’s Association.
The linking of lobsters and ormers with bass merely muddies the waters. Commercial lobster catches are unlimited and ormer limits apply to everybody. In the real world all business has to exist competitively, so surely this is not too much to ask from a few commercial fishermen. There are many avenues they might explore, before blaming their plight on amateurs.
Anyone who sells fish is acting commercially, therefore is not the problem an internal one for their own association? The number of non-professional commercial anglers selling fish is miniscule, and if a problem, other much less drastic solutions are available.
For the last two decades recreational fishermen have been asking that the minimum landing size be brought to a level where bass are allowed to spawn at least once. The main opponents of these measures have been commercial fishermen.
Now that the culinary world is turning to bream, what do we say to Jamie Oliver next spring? ‘Sorry no fish. Last spring the commercial fishermen all agreed to move their static gear so that the French trawlers have unimpeded access to the spawning stock. Go and buy some squashed and bruised fish from them.’ Because this year that happened.
Finally, for years fishermen all over Europe have campaigned not to have to throw top quality over-quota fish dead back into the sea. This proposed legislation will for the first time, introduce that abomination, but only for recreational fishermen.
Nouages Neuvaine,
Chemin au Grèves,
Grouville.
Travel
To, from and around the Island
Airport Arrivals & Departures
Harbours Arrivals & Departures
Bus Information & Timetables
JOIN US ON...
Facebook and Twitter
Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
Got a story? Get in touch
KIT 4 CLUBS
Win a share of £10,000
2012 is the year of the London Olympics and to celebrate this great event the Jersey Evening Post, in association with sponsors Ogier is giving all sporting clubs a chance to win a share of £10,000.
I’m glad you mentioned the French, who Jason Bonhomme thinks we should emulate. Well we are emulating them – by destroying our stocks through over fishing and having a fisheries department which appears to have no desire to introduce any form of legislation relating to conservation so as not to upset the commercial fishermen.
Report abuse
It is fair to say that if the commercial fishermen continue to go at the bass stocks in the way they are going then they will drive the fish to effective extinction in island waters within 15 – 20 years.
The big fish are disappearing from island waters and even fish of spawning size are rarer.
Bass are the iconic game fish in island waters and they now being fished for the table in a way that the population cannot sustain in the long term.
Short term island!
Report abuse
Pip I wouldn’t even give it that long. From what I am hearing about big catches the trawlers have been getting these last few years off of Guernsey I would say more like 5 years. One night’s work for 30-40 tonnes of bass how long can this go on for, in your own honest opinion?
Bream will go the same way as bass if fisheries and the States don’t get a grip before its too late.
Over quota fish being returned dead to the sea another silly idea from those that should know better in my opinion.
Will the commercial fishermen have the “sense” to see sense or will it be a case of carry on regardless? As far as I am concerned pair trawling should be banned asap. It is highly damaging to sustainability is it not? As for allowing other nationalities to fish Jersey waters all I can say is the States must be daft.
As for moving your pots because fishermen from another country want to fish in Jersey waters, you are having a laugh aren’t you? What gives them the right to do this to Jersey fishermen in Jersey waters?
As for tapping up the occasional fisherman to save the fish for those who could well be doing the most damage to fish stocks what is the point in doing this? I would start from the top and work my way down to the level at which sustainability is reached and stop there. Why put the cart before the horse?
Report abuse
Time to stop the blame game and move forward: The bag limit is a wise move if it accompanied by other more realistic conservation measures such as a network of marine reserves, with a buffer area allowing low impact activities such as angling. This would benefit the whole marine ecosystem which is suffering because of the mis management and Jersey is a prime example, dwindling fish stocks, declining sea bird numbers, and water quality issues.
About time there was a realistic body to govern our shoreline and waters, the fisheries panel has failed dismally in this case.
Who is going to manage the French anglers that are already exploiting juvenile stocks often unchecked at the offshore reefs?
Report abuse