When kerbside recycling is rubbish

Wednesday 28th October 2009, 2:59PM GMT.

From Professor Adrian Demaid.
THE UK is a wonderfully rich source of examples of how not to do things.

The most perfect example is the way that a cottage industry of householders is being trained as rubbish sorters in the name of recycling.

My 91-year-old mother has just received her training literature from Solihull Council, together with a complicated calculator and a confusing calendar. Solihull has introduced a five-bin system – the government’s ideal is a six-bin system, so they have some way to go yet.

In the green box she puts all of her paper and cardboard – except wallpaper, envelopes with windows, wrapping paper, corrugated cardboard, greetings cards and tetrapacks (what is a tetrapack?).

The black box is for food and drink cans, aluminium food trays (all to be washed), and the metal caps and lids that she has removed from her glass bottles and jars, which also go in the black box. What doesn’t go in is any other metal item, Pyrex ware, drinking glasses, vases, broken glass and light bulbs.

In the white sack she puts her plastic bottles (all washed and squashed), but not her plastic trays, food tubs, yogurt pots, plastic film, polystyrene and tetrapacks. Tetrapacks are clearly bad news.

In the green bin she puts all garden waste, except branches over 2.5-cm diameter.

The black bin is for anything left over at the end of her daily recycling shift.
These five bins, boxes or sacks are to be put out on the roadside before seven o’clock in the morning on the days of collection.

The green and black box are collected on alternate fortnights, the white sack and black bin weekly – for the moment, as half of England’s local authorities have abandoned weekly bin collections.

The next stage will be to ensure that the trainee workforce is doing the job properly – some ungrateful householders will call this policing.

All of this nonsense-on-stilts harms the planet, turns town streets ugly and, worst of all for those of us concerned about sustainability, it alienates people:
‘Mail on Sunday reported that 25,000 microchips have been removed by angry residents in Bournemouth.’

‘Residents blockade recycling lorry after row over five pebbles in garden waste.’
‘What a waste of time. After filling our white bag with cardboard and plastic for a fortnight, the binmen decided they wouldn’t empty it because we had contaminated it with a plastic tray.’

‘South Oxfordshire householders will demonstrate outside Henley-on-Thames town hall next month, arguing that the bins are an eyesore and unmanageable.’

The States deserve much credit for resisting the siren call of kerbside recycling, but its voice needs to be heard in this, to explain the costs – to the taxpayer, to the householder and to the planet – of these ridiculous schemes.

Otherwise, well, a Nightmare on Kerbside Recycling Street is currently showing in the UK.


  1. 1
    FUBAR

    And there are prisons full of wasters doing nothing. Make them to do the recycling. Hard larbour!!!

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Flymo

    Does anyone think that this has been made unnecessarily complicated? One presumes that the newly created army of waste monitors will ensure that you are fined for a transgression of the rules. Another way of getting money out of the populous.
    Now, can someone please tell me again just how extortion works ….?

    If I recall correctly, I read an article on waste management using plasma gasification technology. Ken Livingstone (as the then mayor of London) wanted to use this idea to reduce the amount of rubbish created until, however, he was informed about the revenue that collection boxes would create.

    At the end of the day, it is all about money ….. and I’m sorry to say, it is your\our money … :-(

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Nathan Jordan

    Having lived in Solihull and S(m)elly Oak while at University, I have had some experience of the recycling Police.

    The council actually refused to let us have a glass bin and said that all glass was to be recycled at our nearest “Greencycle Point” – a large bin for various colours of glass, which was 1.5 miles from where we lived.

    This was all well and fine but most students don’t have a car and the one of my housemates who did, didn’t want to have to cart around a load of dirty glass in her car surprise surprise, forcing us to covertly wrap our empty bottles in paper so no telltale clink would give away our crime to the binmen.

    Moreover the council also decided that it would be a really good idea only to collect our rubbish once every two weeks in a bid to encourage us to recycle. As a household of four people we easily produced eight bags a week on average but were told that if we put it out on the kerbside we would be fined.

    The result of this was that we had to store the bags in our garden for weeks at a time, which attracted flies & rats.

    You may remember rats. They were carriers of the Black Death. These ones burrowed through the plastic sacks to eat the innards, leaving rotting waste all over our garden.

    On several occasions a rat ate something it shouldn’t have (they aren’t very bright) and died horribly, adding its carcass to the mounting pile of organic leavings.

    Sunny days were the most interesting…

    So when the council refuses to collect glass for recycling or take your rubbish, forcing it to pile up and attract vermin & disease into your home, I’m rather inclined to believe that the environment was better off before we started going green…

    NJ.

    Report abuse

KIT 4 CLUBS

Win a share of £10,000 Win a share of £10,000

2012 is the year of the London Olympics and to celebrate this great event the Jersey Evening Post, in association with sponsors Ogier is giving all sporting clubs a chance to win a share of £10,000.