Bottled water could damage our health
Monday 12th July 2010, 3:00PM BST.
From Christopher Davey.
AS reported in your paper (JEP, 10 Jul) we should all be giving full-hearted backing to the ECO-Active Ban-the-Bottled-Water campaign, as supported by the Environment Department.
Three years ago I found myself at a reunion dinner at the Savoy Hotel in London. As a non-wine diner I requested water, and was offered UK Spring Water at £5 per litre or water specially imported from Fiji at £9 per litre.
Once I had picked myself up off the floor, I demanded, with bad grace, to be served with good ‘multi-recycled’ London tap water at no charge.
Following subsequent research, I discovered that an American factory in Fiji was bottling ground water, with the dire environmental consequence that the water-table had fallen so low that the local inhabitants were being deprived of their natural resource. Unbelievably, this water was then being shipped across the globe at massive environmental cost.
Another serious aspect that your article does not cover is the effect of heat reacting with the chemicals in water bottle plastic.
Research has shown that dioxins are released, which is a toxin that is increasingly found in breast cancer tissue. Maybe this is could be a useful cause for our Chief Medical Officer to take up as well.
In the meantime people should be strongly warned against drinking plastic bottled water that has been left lying in the car, particularly if it has been irradiated by the sun.
The Queen's Diamond Jubilee
JEP Jubilee Editions
Saturday 2 June: Guide to Celebrations
Wednesday 6 June: Souvenir of Events
View The Queen in Jersey supplement
Travel
To, from and around the Island
Airport Arrivals/Departures
Harbours Arrivals/Departures
Bus Information/Timetables
Before everyone starts panicking about heated/frozen water bottles, perhaps they should spend a few minutes to read this reponse from Johns Hopkins University
http://www.jhsph.edu/dioxins
Report abuse
#1 We should also check what the nanny state add to water. I’ll trust the bottled water of companies that I have personal knowledge of far more than I will ever trust water that governments get involved in!
Report abuse
#1 No we shouldn’t, we should simply look to more eco-friendly ways to get a hold of and of containing non-tap water, and at better recycling facilities. It would be a stretch too far, even for modern-day nanny states, to ban bottled water and force everyone to drink the tap water that some genuinely do not like (and so won’t drink!) Of course those that don’t like it may simply switch to other drinks that come in plastic bottles, so would they be banned too?
Even if Jersey did move towards banning bottled water there would be a need for the public to have an absolute guarantee that Jersey will never resort to adding fluorine to its water. Then there is the price of tap water, what do you think will happen to that? Are we really naive enough to think someone won’t milk the success of such a campaign?
#1 has made the other points.
Report abuse