Let’s talk things over in public

Thursday 26th May 2011, 3:00PM BST.

From Ted Vibert.
JOHN Boothman (JEP, 18 May) is full of accusations but totally unable to back them up with facts. When he wrote his last letter about me and the JDA in November last year, he wrote about me having ‘nihilistic policies’. I challenged him to produce any policy I have ever supported that could be described as ‘nihilistic’ in this way. Silence.

In his previous letter Mr Boothman also advised me that I should choose my friends more wisely. Such pompous arrogance is hard to understand in this so-called enlightened day and age but political dinosaurs don’t seem to learn any lessons.

He claims that I ‘snuggle up’ to the Tax Justice Network. I am not a ‘snuggler’ but I do sit comfortably at the same table and on the same level with men of intellect who are highly talented, generous (in terms of their time towards helping Jersey) thoughtful and moral.

People like Richard Murphy, John Christensen, Professor Jacques Harel of the Institute d’Etudes Politiques de Rennes, Nicholas Shaxson, author of ‘Treasure Islands – tax havens and the men who stole the world’ and Prem Sikka, Professor of Accounting at Essex University.

When Richard Murphy came to Jersey recently to deliver his ‘ethical banking’ proposal, Mr Boothman and his mates failed to turn up.

So much to say from the comfort of their bunkers but so little to say face-to-face. Such political cowardice is typical of this group.

In my last letter, I challenged Mr Boothman to stand in the Senatorial elections and let’s see who is ‘equipped for the task’. I repeat that challenge. I also challenged him to publicly debate the issues with me.
He wouldn’t.

So I now issue him with another challenge to publicly debate with me at the Town Hall the motion: That the finance industry has given Jersey more problems than benefits.

While I can understand his fear of crossing swords publicly with people of the calibre of Richard Murphy, why would he be afraid of me?
So here’s your chance Mr Boothman to prove that I am ‘ill-equipped for the task of being in the States’. Come and publicly humiliate me with your superior intellect and knowledge. After all, I am just a Jersey bean from Grosnez. Rise to the challenge and defend your industry.I dare you.


  1. 1
    Hello

    Now, is this your letter or Geoff Southern’s letter? Let’s not have any confusion here, please.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    joker

    This guy’s sounding more like Syvret every day.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    tony

    Not the greatest of fans of Mr Vibert but this could be a very interesting public debate balls in your court Mr Boothman!!

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    halo

    I don’t think he does sound like Syvret but I am encouraged by the thought that he might do. Goodness knows, we need someone to replace former Senator Syvret in the house, if only as some effective chack and balance against the backwards looking arrogance and abuse of office which has flowed from ministerial government.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Fred Zeppelin

    “This guy’s sounding more like Syvret every day.”

    Oh my, the right wing is getting twitchy! TV must be doing something right.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    joker

    halo #4

    So are you saying we need someone representing us that has an ego so inflated they think they’re above the law and when they’re brought to justice they will hide in the UK and then run across to Europe to have their case laughed out of Court? We’re doomed.

    Fred Zepplelin #5

    That’s quite a stretch: someone automatically being right wing because they didn’t agree with Syvret or his blog rants. Good to see as a follower your not too shy of an unsubstantiated accusation yourself. Good work.

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    toker

    Joker at 6, well, yes, that’s exactly what we’re saying. Well spotted!

    Syvret did of course return to the island after the search on his property and other delights and, if he does go to Europe, he won’t be running, rather he’ll be availing himself of a judicial avenue to which he and anyone else is entitled. The higher courts are extremely busy with people “running” to them! I guess we are doomed, if his treatment is the mark of what jersey has become. That’s the dictatorial left for you.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Dave

    Is Mr Boothman standing in the next election? He seems to be courting a lot of publicity in the media recently.

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    joker

    toker #7

    My reference to “above the law” wasn’t referring to his house search. Do some research into the matter and you’ll see where I’m coming from. The man thinks he’s being victimised when he blatently broke a law you and I would be answerable to.

    Report abuse

KIT 4 CLUBS

Win a share of £10,000 Win a share of £10,000

2012 is the year of the London Olympics and to celebrate this great event the Jersey Evening Post, in association with sponsors Ogier is giving all sporting clubs a chance to win a share of £10,000.